The American Ring is more uncomfortably American than we might wish.

The American Ring in the American Capital

One of the many rewards of attending Francesca Zambello’s production of the “American Ring” for the second time recently in Washington, DC, is the chance to admire, and chew on, the insights that she offers.  It is one thing to set the action of the Ring in the American mythological past – for example, to see Alberich in the shallows of the pristine Colorado River, panning for gold nuggets.  It is quite another to consider how close our society is to the themes that are central or Wagner’s concerns.

On example is offered by the video sequences that intermittently accompany orchestral preludes or scene changes.  Many of them show railroad tracks, or travel – a fundamental and unique aspect of the American imagination.  Indeed, the second scene of Walküre is set below a freeway, on which travelers zip by, oblivious to the squalor beneath them.

zambello 1



And facilitating that travel we see utility poles, construction, electricity, coal mines, and other similarly themed images.

Rhinegold, WNO

Rhinegold, WNO

Setting Valhalla in a modern skyscraper is no not-new as to be disappointing.  But in this “American Ring,” it becomes an expression of energy.


Mining is there to create electricity.  And utility lines are … power.


Thus, the images that are offered cohere the production and remind us that power – what Americans do every day when we walk into a room or turn on an oven – is what both America and the Ring are all about.  We Americans seek, create, expand, and take for granted the easy access to power all the time.  And we have done so it the sacrifice of the natural world.  Where there once were salmon there now are dams, and where there once were hills there now are mines.  World Ash, anyone?

In such a world littered with discarded debris and detritus, why shouldn’t a giant on the run convert himself into a fearsome trash compactor?


Thus we are asked by this production:  How remote and mythological are the Niebelungs and the gods to our present society, that is made possible only by the creation of power/energy, at the cost of the beauty and authority of the natural world?

[Prior postings on this production, reflecting its first run at the San Francisco Opera, are available here and here.]

Tristan and Isolde at the English National Opera

The new production of Tristan at the English National Opera (seen June 15, 2016) is very good indeed, and I’m sure a relief to all fans of this wonderful institution.  It was in this auditorium that I first experienced the Ring under Goodall – and, ironically, this performance of Tristan was dedicated to Alberto Remedios, […]

James Levine Says Lieb Wohl

Some music-making of a very high caliber took place at New York’s Carnegie Hall on the evening of May 26, 2016, when James Levine closed out a three-concert series by the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra with selections from the Ring Cycle. The Met Orchestra has, for years, been by far the best band in New York, […]

Once More to the River

Tomorrow I drive down to Washington to attend the Ring.  It will be my 17th.  My first, at age 25, was the Goodall English-language production at the Coliseum in London, in December 1975, just after I graduated from the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. I find myself as excited to hear that E-flat as I […]